Climate Walkers 
          reach Albay Province, the “climate change capital” of the Philippines
          Press Release
          October 22, 2014
          LEGAZPI CITY – Today, 
          over a thousand people participated in the Albay leg of the “People’s 
          Walk for Climate Justice”. Albay Governor Joey Salceda welcomed the 
          group who have walked a distance of 500 kilometers and are now more 
          than halfway in their quest to reach Tacloban City by November 8, the 
          first anniversary of super typhoon Yolanda’s historic landfall in the 
          Philippines.
          “Albay welcomes these 
          climate advocates, our modern-day heroes who are raising awareness on 
          climate change and are fighting the climate fight on behalf of 
          millions of Filipinos who are bearing the brunt of extreme weather 
          events that often cause disasters and human misery,” said Salceda.
          A staunch supporter of the 
          climate revolution and a champion for disaster risk reduction and 
          climate change adaptation efforts, Governor Salceda spent his birthday 
          by joining the climate walkers.
          Hailed by the UN as the role 
          model on good practices on disaster risk reduction program, Albay 
          province consistently follows through with its goal of “zero casualty” 
          in times of calamities whether it be from typhoons, landslides, 
          floods, storm surges. This goal will again be put to a test with the 
          pending eruption of Mayon Volcano. 
          
          The province is also lauded 
          for its climate change adaptation (CCA) efforts, with Governor Salceda 
          being the prime mover of the CCA program that led to a commitment 
          between national and local government. 
          
          “Albay has a zero casualty 
          policy as far as disaster impacts is concerned. We have also created 
          the institutional frameworks to deal both with climate change and 
          disaster risks, and have set aside budgets to reduce future risks from 
          the impacts of climate change, including through our work to achieve 
          the Millennium Development Goals. Dealing with climate change and 
          disaster risks is the responsibility of chief executives of local 
          government and cannot be delegated or outsourced,” Salceda added.
          Ron Villafuerte, a 
          Greenpeace volunteer climate walker and a proud native of Bicol, 
          called on the leaders of other cities to follow suit and transition to 
          a more resilient, low carbon pathway. “The Philippines can lead the 
          climate revolution if we replicate the efforts and commitments done by Albay province to the rest of the country.” 
          
          Now on its 21st day, the 
          climate walk seeks to raise awareness on climate change by getting 
          commitments from local policymakers and holding climate programs in 
          communities, schools and local government offices, sharing stories of 
          local folk on the ground and mobilizing people in demanding world 
          leaders to take climate action and holding big industry polluters and 
          their respective governments accountable for their contribution to the 
          climate crisis. 
          
          “Imagine what the world 
          would be like if we had more progressive leaders that value nature and 
          the environment, to ensure a habitable planet for all their citizens. 
          I dedicate this walk to support the call for climate justice because I 
          refuse to succumb to a life that is doomed to the impacts of climate 
          change,” concludes Villafuerte.
          For more information on the 
          Climate Walk: A People’s Walk for Climate Justice, please go to 
          http://climatewalknow.wordpress.com/support/
 
 
 
 
          Labor group wants 
          Petilla’s head for deceiving the Filipino people bigtime over 
          so-called power crisis
          By NAGKAISA
          October 22, 2014
          QUEZON CITY – A 
          coalition of 49 labor groups and workers’ organizations called 
          Nagkaisa is demanding President Aquino to immediately fire Energy 
          Secretary Jericho Petilla for deceiving the Filipino people with his 
          manufactured power shortage scenario hitting the entire island of 
          Luzon early 2015.
          Officials of the Department 
          of Energy admitted during a congressional hearing that the projected 
          deficit in supply for the coming summer of 2015 is only about 21 to 31 
          MW, a far cry from the 1,200 MW shortfall trumpeted by Petilla.
          “It is now very clear to us 
          that Secretary Petilla took the country for a ride. He bluffed the 
          president, the cabinet, the senators and the congressmen, the business 
          sectors, the labor and consumer groups with his tall tales of thin 
          power reserves to justify emergency powers that entails possible 
          purchase of multi-billion peso generator sets. Mr. Petilla 
          deliberately exposed the country to unnecessary jeopardy that has been 
          discouraging job-creating investments away since he came out with his 
          bogus story in July,” Josua Mata of Sentro-Nagkaisa, one of Nagkaisa 
          convenors said reading Nagkaisa statement.
          “This is a grave crime to 
          the Filipino people. The only way for Secretary Petilla to redeem 
          himself, after having been rebuffed by congressmen for his exaggerated 
          numbers on the alleged looming power crisis, is to apologize to the 
          people and submit an irrevocable resignation. If he doesn’t have the 
          delicadeza to do so, we are demanding his head from the president. 
          Either way, the Filipino people does not deserve a reprehensible 
          nincompoop in government,” he added.
          “Instead of asking congress 
          to hastily grant him emergency powers, President Aquino should first 
          kick his energy man out for his failure to lead a critical department 
          of the executive,” Wilson Fortaleza, spokesperson of Partido 
          Manggagawa-Nagkaisa.
          Fortaleza said Petilla’s 
          main blunder is the absence of policy intervention and the heap of 
          unsound options in addressing the looming power crisis.
          Petilla has proposed costly 
          lease agreements from independent power producers to fill up the 
          capacity gap in two years. Another option was to top existing 
          capacities from industries’ embedded generator sets under the 
          Interruptible Load Program (ILP).
          “Petilla must go not because 
          power emergency is none existent but also because policy intervention 
          is absent. The president must fire him for deceiving the entire nation 
          including himself as the chief executive and his fellow members of the 
          cabinet,” added Fortaleza.
          Another convenor, Louie 
          Corral, executive director of Trade Union Congress of the Philippines-Nagakisa, 
          explained that had the government acted as early as 2011, we could 
          have started building new capacities by building new power plants; 
          forced private power to rationalize their scheduled maintenance 
          shutdowns; optimize the use of every plant especially hydro; and 
          exercised strong regulatory powers to prevent market fraud.
          Yet these options, Fortaleza 
          said, can still be utilized right now as these powers are present 
          under DOE’s mandate, the Energy Regulatory Commission (ERC), the 
          Office of the President, and Congress under the Joint Congressional 
          Power Commission (JCPC). 
          
          “The only time we will 
          support emergency powers is when the government finally decides to 
          take over the whole industry with the utmost objectives of bringing 
          down the price and securing a sustainable power supply not only for 
          present needs but also for the next generations to come,” concluded 
          Corral.
          The Nagkaisa is a coalition 
          of labor unions and workers’ organizations who band together three 
          years ago to advance security of tenure, reduce the price of 
          electricity, empower public sector workers and improve workers living 
          wage. The members of the coalition are the Alliance of Free Workers (AFW) 
          All Filipino Workers Confederation (AFWC), Automobile Industry Workers 
          Alliance (AIWA), Alab Katipunan, Association of Genuine Labor 
          Organizations (AGLO), Associated Labor Unions (ALU), Associated Labor 
          Unions- Association of Professional Supervisory Officers Technical 
          Employees Union (ALU-APSOTEU), ALU-Metal, Associated Labor 
          Unions-Philippine Seafarers’Union (ALU-PSU), ALU-Textile, ALU-Transport, 
          Associated Labor Unions-Visayas Mindanao Confederation of Trade Unions 
          (ALU-VIMCOMTU), Alliance of Progressive Labor (APL), Association of 
          Trade Unions (ATU), Bukluran ng Manggagawang Pilipino (BMP), 
          Confederation of Independent Unions (CIU), Confederation of Labor and 
          Allied Social Services (CLASS), Construction Workers Solidarity (CWS), 
          Federation of Coca-Cola Unions (FCCU), Federation of Free Workers (FFW), 
          Kapisanan ng Maralitang Obrero (KAMAO), Katipunan, Pambansang Kilusan 
          sa Paggawa (KILUSAN), Kapisanan ng mga Kawani sa Koreo sa Pilipinas (KKKP), 
          Labor education and Research Network (LEARN), League of Independent 
          Bank Organizations (LIBO), Manggagawa para sa Kalayaan ng Bayan (MAKABAYAN), 
          MARINO, National Association of Broadcast Unions (NABU), National 
          Federation of Labor Unions (NAFLU), National Mines and Allied Workers 
          Union (NAMAWU), National Association of Trade Unions (NATU), National 
          Confederation of Labor (NCL), National Confederation of Transport 
          Union (NCTU), National Union of Portworkers in the Philippines (NUPP), 
          National Union of Workers in Hotel, Restaurant and Allied Industries (NUWHRAIN), 
          Philippine Airlines Employees Association (PALEA), Pepsi Cola 
          Employees Union of the Philippines (PEUP), Philippine Government 
          Employees Association (PGEA), Pinag-isang Tinig at Lakas ng Anakpawis 
          (PIGLAS), Philippine Integrated Industries Labor Union (PILLU), 
          Philippine Independent Public Sector Employees Association (PIPSEA), 
          Partido Manggagawa (PM), Philippine Metalworkers Alliance (PMA), 
          Public Services Labor Independent Confederation (PSLINK), Philippine 
          Transport and General Workers Organization (PTGWO), SALIGAN, Trade 
          Union Congress of the Philippines (TUCP), Workers Solidarity Network (WSN).
 
 
 
 
At the Senate Committee of 
          Foreign Relations’ hearing
          Karapatan stands 
          firm: VFA blocks justice for Laude's murder
          By KARAPATAN
          October 22, 2014
          QUEZON CITY – "The 
          killing of transgender woman Jennifer Laude by a US serviceman is a 
          heinous violation of human rights," Karapatan secretary general, 
          Cristina Palabay, told the Senate today during the hearing initiated 
          by Senator Miriam Defensor-Santiago, chairperson of the Committee on 
          Foreign Relations.
          "The current situation of 
          human rights violations committed with impunity is already bad as it 
          is. The VFA and recently approved Enhanced Defense Cooperation 
          Agreement worsen the situation," Palabay told the Senate. "The 
          political will of the current administration to prosecute fully the 
          case is also questionable, given the skewed political relationship 
          between the US and Philippine governments," Palabay said.
          Laude’s killing, she said, 
          “reflects the realities in Philippine society on the extent of 
          prevalent gender-based violence, the climate of impunity, and the 
          geo-political structures that exist." These are issues that are swept 
          under the rug by spinmeisters hired to deemphasize the enormity and 
          the roots of the problem.
          Palabay said “the killing of 
          Laude and similar rights violations are acts that are legitimized 
          because of judicial system that turns its blind eye to justice.” She 
          added that “perpetrators of human rights violation in this country are 
          usually free from arrests, detention and conviction."
          Palabay zeroed in on the 
          lopsided military agreements between the US and Philippine governments 
          which provides the context of the crime committed against Jennifer. 
          Palabay scored the US-RP Military Bases Agreement and the Visiting 
          Forces Agreement.
          She mentioned the rape of 
          12-year old Rosario Baluyot who died of sepsis because parts of a 
          vibrator inserted in her vagina remained since her rape for seven 
          months. Palabay also cited the rape of "Nicole" by US marine Daniel 
          Smith in 2005. In both cases, the US soldiers accused of raping these 
          girls were shipped out from the Philippines.
          Palabay also enumerated a 
          long list of atrocities committed by US soldiers against the Filipino 
          people: the shooting Buyong-buyong Isnijal by Sgt. Reggie Lane; the 
          killing of the Dr. Julius Ceasar Aguila who testified that Isnijal was 
          brought by Sgt. Lane and two other US soldiers in the hospital he was 
          working; the shooting of Arsid Baharun in 2004 by a US soldier; and, 
          the mysterious murder of Gregan Cardeno in 2010 while inside a US 
          facility in Camp Ranao, Marawi City and the subsequent death of 
          Cardeno’s friend, Capt. Javier Ignacio who helped the Cardeno family 
          shed light on Gregan's death.
 
 
 
 
          PRO8 creates 
          honesty team to weed out erring PNP personnel
          By RPCRD, Police Regional 
          Office 8
          October 20, 2014
          CAMP RUPERTO K KANGLEON, 
          Palo, Leyte – Police Regional Office 8 thru the leadership of 
          PCSupt. Henry P. Losañes, PRO8 Regional Director, issued a Command 
          Memorandum Circular creating a PRO8 Honesty Teams. The operational 
          guidelines is set to be followed by the PRO8 personnel in enhancing 
          the image of the Philippine National Police through a comprehensive 
          program to weed out erring PNP personnel engaged in extortion or “kotong”, 
          “hulidap”, “mulcting”, “bribery” and other forms of illegal 
          activities.
          The memorandum revealed that 
          these illegal activities usually occur but not limited to the 
          following: during the conduct of an investigation; issuance of PNP 
          clearances/licenses; traffic violation; illegal vending, and delivery 
          of goods, fruits, vegetables, livestock, meat, fish by traders or “viajeros”. 
          Some are involved in “hulidap” or arresting the people on trumped-up 
          charges and demanding settlement money. They also prey on PNP 
          personnel who seek reassignment or promotion.
          According to General Losañes, 
          PPOs and CPOs will likewise initiate the organization of Honesty Team 
          to conduct an intensive region-wide campaign against erring PNP 
          personnel engaged in extortion and other form of illegal activities.
          The operation concept of 
          this memorandum consists of three (3) components: 1. Target 
          Areas/Personalities Acquisitions; 2. Reinforcement of PNP Core Values; 
          3. Neutralization Operations. A sub-term for each component shall be 
          correspondingly created.
          He added that a diligent 
          intelligence gathering will be undertaken to identify the 
          units/offices and areas of deployment, susceptible to acts or 
          transaction that might lead to extortion or other forms of illegal 
          activities including the personnel who are likely to commit or those 
          who are already involved in such illegal acts.
          Active and consistence 
          education and information dissemination campaign will also be 
          initiated in the entire region, prioritizing those police 
          units/offices and areas of deployment that have been identified to be 
          vulnerable to commission of misdemeanors, with particular focus on 
          already known target personalities. The education campaign shall 
          concentrate in inculcating the core values of the PNP organization in 
          order to avoid the occurrence or commission of illegal acts that are 
          subject of the Memorandum.
          Those involved or who will 
          persist in their nefarious activities will be arrested and criminally 
          charged without prejudice to administrative sanctions.
          The PNP TEXT 2920, walk-in 
          complaints, CI activities, and dialogue with concerned sectors, i.e. 
          transport, etc. shall serve as feedback mechanisms to reinforce the 
          efforts of the PNP in formulating strategies to rid corruption within 
          its ranks.
          This is one of the 
          initiatives of the PNP to enhance the image of the PNP not only in 
          Eastern Visayas but also in the whole country.
          The public is assured that 
          the PNP will remain relentless in maintaining peace and order and 
          enforcing the law without fear or favor.
 
 
 
 
          Groups demand immediate 
          return of Canadian toxic waste; Call for PHL to ban toxic wastes trade
          Press Release
          October 21, 2014
          MANILA – As the illegal Canadian toxic waste shipments fester in 
          Philippine ports for 16 months, public furor over the Canadian 
          government’s brazen defiance of international law erupted anew in 
          Manila as environment and public health groups staged a street protest 
          in front of the Department of Foreign Affairs (DFA) commemorating the 
          signing of the flawed international treaty on toxic waste trade called 
          the Basel Convention.
          Twenty-one years after the Philippine government ratified the Basel 
          Convention it continues to labor under the threat of toxic waste 
          trade. With the latest illegal Canadian toxic wastes, the public is 
          demanding the DFA and the Department of Environment and Natural 
          Resources to initiate the ratification process of the Basel Ban 
          Amendment to prevent the Philippines from becoming a global toxic 
          waste dump site.
          Although the Philippines is a party to the Basel Convention, 
          environmental groups said that the Basel Convention has loopholes, 
          which toxic waste traders capitalize on. For one, it only requires 
          prior consent from the receiving country to initiate toxic waste 
          export, but more importantly, destination countries such as the 
          Philippines are left to their own devices to police and intercept 
          illegal waste shipments. 
          
          “As far back as 1995, developing countries tried to erect barriers to 
          protect themselves from toxic waste dumping by amending the Basel 
          Convention with what is now called the Basel Ban. The logic behind 
          this amendment was simple; let those who generate toxic wastes deal 
          with their wastes. And what better way to do this than banning these 
          noxious exports,” explained BAN Toxics executive director Atty. 
          Richard Gutierrez.
          The Basel Ban Amendment, an amendment to the Basel Convention, 
          prohibits the movement of hazardous wastes from developed to poorer 
          countries for any reason, whether it be for disposal or recycling.
          “This disgraceful hazardous waste trade in the Philippines needs to 
          stop. We demand that the Philippines Senate ratify the Basel Ban 
          Amendment immediately and promote clean production, stop toxic 
          technologies and prevent governments and companies from circumventing 
          the recycling loophole in the Basel Convention,” said Abigail Aguilar, 
          toxics campaigner for Greenpeace Philippines.
          Meanwhile, EcoWaste Coalition calls for President Benigno Aquino III’s 
          intervention to ensure the ratification of the Basel Ban Amendment.
          “The infuriating presence of the stinking Canadian garbage in our soil 
          despite being declared illegal by our customs and environmental 
          officials is a shameful slap on the face of every Filipino. If the DFA 
          or the DENR cannot end this travesty of justice, we ask President 
          Aquino himself to intercede, defend our national dignity and our right 
          to a healthy and safe environment. The presidential intervention and 
          the Senate ratification of the Basel Ban Amendment should send a 
          clear-cut signal to all waste generators and traders that our country 
          is not a landfill to the world," said Aileen Lucero, coordinator, 
          EcoWaste Coalition.
          Earlier this year, the Bureau of Customs (BOC) seized 50 container 
          vans containing waste materials imported from Canada, with the 
          consignee Chronic Plastics, Inc. declaring the shipment as ‘assorted 
          scrap plastic materials for recycling’. However, upon inspection of 
          the BOC, it was revealed that the shipment contains mixed hazardous 
          wastes, including hospital waste, used adult diapers, and sanitary 
          napkins, which continue to rot and leachate, posing great risk to 
          public health.
          “We need a collective effort to solve this problem. We are asking for 
          DFA to make a firm stand on the issue. Would you just allow the 
          Canadian garbage to stay in our country? Or will you do what former 
          Secretary Domingo Siazon did with the issue of the Japanese garbage? 
          Aside from respecting and adhering to the provisions of Basel 
          Convention we have pressing issues on the impacts on health and the 
          environment,” said Ang NARS Representative Leah Paquiz.
          While the botched importation of the Canadian toxic wastes shipment is 
          a clear violation of the Basel Convention, the groups scored the 
          Philippine government for giving in to suggestions from the Canadian 
          government to permanently dispose of the toxic wastes shipment in the 
          country. 
          “Filipinos have labored under a series of administrations that value 
          toxic wastes more than the public’s right to a healthful ecology. The 
          fact that the government has twiddled its thumbs for over 20 years on 
          the issue of toxic waste dumping, shows that there are a few who 
          benefit from this criminal trade, and that administrations past and 
          present have been unwilling or have decided to look the other way,” 
          Gutierrez said.
          “The illegal Canadian toxic waste export is a testament to this awful 
          truth.” Gutierrez added.
          In an effort to gain public attention on the issue, the coalition 
          filed an online petition on change.org that drew 23,600 signers, more 
          than half of which are Canadians. The group is encouraging more people 
          to sign the online petition to appeal and urge the Canadian embassy in 
          the Philippines to facilitate the pick up and return of the garbage 
          back to the Canadian soil. 
          
          Joining AngNars, BAN Toxics, Greenpeace, and Ecowaste Coalition are 
          Mother Earth Foundation, Global Alliance for Incinerator Alternatives, 
          Green Convergence, and the Ateneo School of Government.
 
 
 
 
As Congress reconvenes
          Hundreds March 
          to Batasan vs. Emergency Powers and the pork-riddled 2015 Budget
          By SANLAKAS and 
          BMP
          October 20, 2014
          QUEZON CITY – 
          Hundreds of urban poor, workers and farmers marched into Batasan as 
          Congress reconvened Monday, October 20. Members of SANLAKAS, Bukluran 
          ng Manggagawang Pilipino (BMP), Partido Lakas ng Masa (PLM), Kongreso 
          ng Pagkakaisa ng Maralitang Lungsod (KPML) and Aniban ng Manggagawa sa 
          Agrikultura (AMA) rallied in front of Congress to oppose a plan to 
          sign a Joint Resolution Granting Emergency Powers to President Aquino, 
          and the passage of the 2015 Budget, which Congress is set to pass 
          within the next few days before going into recess again on October 30.
          President Aquino asked 
          Congress to grant him emergency powers in order to address an 
          anticipated power crisis in 2015, based on Energy Secretary Jericho 
          Petilla’s projections. But debates among government officials continue 
          over whether this power crisis is real or not. Officials have also 
          been divided over solutions to the anticipated shortfall in power by 
          2015 when Malampaya for its regular maintenance shutdown.
          Says Atty. Aaron Pedrosa of 
          SANLAKAS, “the President’s determination of a power shortage by 2015 
          is one based on conjecture absent of substantiation. What the 
          government intends to do is to rent out power barges and diesel 
          generation sets at an estimated contract price of P14 Billion for a 
          two-year lease. This is a short-sighted approach and does not address 
          the real problems plaguing a deregulated power industry. It diverts 
          the public from the real power crisis that has defined the industry 
          for more than a decade now thanks to EPIRA.”
          Gie Relova of BMP 
          elaborated, “To date, 2.7 million households remain without access to 
          electricity; the country’s power rates are the most expensive in Asia 
          and rank fifth in the world; market manipulation and collusion are at 
          its worst with prices being manipulated in the Wholesale Electricity 
          Spot Market (WESM), defying a cornerstone promise of EPIRA – of 
          providing affordable and reliable electricity to the people. More than 
          13 years after EPIRA was passed, a mere five families control the 
          power industry.”
          Atty. Pedrosa adds, 
          “Emergency powers will only result in socializing more obligations 
          that the government intends to pursue. To this day, we are paying for 
          the take or pay provisions and sovereign guarantees extended by the 
          Ramos Administration when it was granted emergency powers allowing it 
          to enter into lopsided supply contracts with independent power 
          producers. That burden will be augmented with the proposal to enter 
          into contracts with private firms for the lease of their generation 
          sets. It is the people who will in the end foot the bill.”
          “The power crisis is bigger 
          than a mere projected shortfall. It requires a solution that 
          recognizes the failure of a paradigm that puts the burden of providing 
          for our power needs in private hands. Emergency power is not the 
          solution,” Pedrosa concluded.
          The groups also decried the 
          passage of the 2015 budget, which they described as “pork-ridden”, and 
          which continues to allow lump-sum, therefore discretionary, 
          appropriations, such as the Presidential Special Purpose Fund. “The 
          Pork Barrel System is alive, and will continue to drain our resources, 
          and deprive the people of funds for such basic needs as housing, 
          education and health,” decried Orly Gallardo of the KPML.
          BMP’s Relova raised the 
          alarm with regard the insertion of the provision for the redefinition 
          of “savings”, “ala- DAP that in effect will now allow the President to 
          use or misuse the funds by simply declaring funds as ‘savings’ at any 
          time of the year so long as he declares it ‘justifiable’.”
          The groups, who have 
          launched a movement called ARM the People (All Resist Movement), vowed 
          to undertake continuous mass actions in light of “Noynoy’s blatant 
          abuse of his executive powers, such as seen in his use of DAP and 
          challenge vs. the Supreme Court resolution, and his bid to, not only 
          legalize this practice but to acquire more through emergency powers”.
 
 
 
 
          P54-B for MRT-3 
          buy-out most likely to be slashed from DOTC 2015 budget – Chiz
          By Office of Senator Chiz 
          Escudero
          October 20, 2014
          PASAY CITY – The 
          Department of Transportation and Communications’ (DOTC) plan to buy 
          out the Metro Rail Transit 3 (MRT 3) for almost P54 billion is 
          unprogrammed and is not reflected in the 2015 General Appropriations 
          Act (GAA), Senator Chiz Escudero said.
          Escudero, chairman of the 
          Senate Committee on Finance, said the P54 billion which the DOTC has 
          set aside for the takeover of the MRT 3 will be sourced from a loan, 
          and not from the national treasury.
          “That amount which was 
          authorized by DOF (Department of Finance) Secretary Cesar Purisima to 
          effect the MRT 3 buyout is actually a loan. Thus, although it is 
          unprogrammed once the loan has been signed, it will reflect in the GAA 
          and the DOTC is apparently to push through with the buyout,” Escudero 
          said.
          He, however, said he is most 
          likely to slash the amount from the GAA or realign it to more 
          essential services for the general public like the much needed 
          infrastructure to ease traffic congestion and disaster preparedness 
          programs.
          “While it is true that we 
          need to improve our mass transport system, I have not been convinced 
          by the DOTC that a takeover with a very high price tag is what we need 
          at this time. One, that P54 billion is not enough as MRTH (Metro Rail 
          Transit Holdings) said the equity value buyout amounts to P112 
          billion. Where did DOTC get that figure? Who did they talk to?” 
          Escudero said.
          The senator said the amount 
          DOTC is appropriating as opposed to MRTH’s asking price is worthless 
          and might just go to waste. “Even DOTC Secretary Abaya said in the 
          hearings that even after they take over MRT 3, the only upshot is 
          better terms for the government when it bids out the operation and 
          maintenance. The DOTC can bid that out now without shelling out P54 
          billion of taxpayer’s money,” Escudero pointed out.
          He is also wary that the 
          bulk of the takeover appropriation will just be used to pay for the 
          bonds held by state-owned Land Bank of the Philippines and Development 
          Bank of the Philippines.
          “Granting we pay the bonds 
          in LBP and DBP, which are technically government anyway, why scrape 
          Juan dela Cruz’s tight resources? The remaining balance is too 
          miniscule to really own back MRT 3, why force the issue then?”
          The DOF will go on an 
          executive session with the Senate today to discuss the MRT 3.
          Asked if this is a session 
          to convince senators to give their stamp of approval for the planned 
          takeover, the senator is skeptic that he will be convinced. “We will 
          see. And I don’t understand the need for a closed-door session. Why 
          can it not be discussed in public? The public has the right to know 
          why that money is needed and how is it going to be spent. That is our 
          money, everyone’s money anyway.”