Greenpeace and
MASIPAG ask the SC to uphold the Writ of Kalikasan on BtTalong field
trials
By
GREENPEACE
March 5, 2014
MANILA, Philippines –
Today, Greenpeace and members of the Magsasaka at Siyentipiko para sa
Pagunlad ng Agrikultura (MASIPAG) trooped to the Supreme Court to ask
that the courts uphold the Writ of Kalikasan on the field trials of
the genetically-modified organism (GMO) BtTalong. The green groups
filed their consolidated legal arguments to counter the maneuver by
pro-GMO groups who are seeking to overturn the Writ of Kalikasan
granted in May 2012 to protect the rights of Filipinos to a balanced
and healthy ecology.
The Court of Appeals, in
ruling with finality last September 20, 2013, recognized that BtTalong
field trials violate the rights of Filipinos to a balanced and healthy
ecology. As such, the CA ordered the GMO proponents to cease and
desist from conducting any field trial of BtTalong and also to protect
and rehabilitate the environment. Instead of implementing the order of
the court, the proponents petitioned the highest court to review the
CA decision.
“Six months after CA upheld
the Writ of Kalikasan, the respondents have yet to prove that they
have indeed carried out the orders set forth by the court. Instead,
after several follow ups, the only information made available to the
public was that the field trials have been stopped. However, they did
not disclose any concrete plans to check and remedy GMO contamination
caused by the field trials,” said Daniel Ocampo, Sustainable
Agriculture Campaigner for Greenpeace Philippines.
The CA’s decision prevented
the proponents of BtTalong from applying for commercial propagation or
from seeking support and acceptance of the project from local
governments in the Philippines. It will be recalled that in early
2010, proponents announced that the Philippines would be the first
country where Bt eggplant will be made commercially available after it
was rejected in India. Filipino regulators even expressed that they
would not be conducting risk assessments and accepted the same
submissions submitted to Indian authorities.
“If we are not vigilant,
Filipinos will again end up as victims, subjected to the inherent
risks associated with GMOs due to the lack of regard of those tasked
to regulate and protect our rights,” said Dr. Chito Medina, National
Coordinator of MASIPAG. “GMOs should not be the sole jurisdiction of
scientists because their long-term environmental, health and
socio-economic impacts will affect all Filipinos once they are
released outside the laboratories. Why risk our nation’s health in the
long run?”
Greenpeace maintains that
genetically modified crops like BtTalong are unnecessary and take away
resources that can better be used to further ecological farming. Money
and resources spent on GMO research limits capacity for research and
development of real, scientific ecological farming solutions. The
group continues to call on the Philippine government to focus on
developing and supporting ecological farming as a way to boost the
country’s agriculture and food production, instead of promoting GMOs
or the use of agrochemicals.